02Ice or chiller
Do you need a chiller, or is ice enough?
You do not need a chiller to start, and a $140 pod plus bagged ice is the cheapest way to find out if you will keep plunging. Ice gets expensive quickly, though. Cooling 70 gallons from 60F to 50F takes about 36 lb, roughly $6.77 at Walmart prices, every time the water warms back up.
How much ice it really takes
Ice cools water in two steps. Each pound absorbs about 144 BTU just to melt, then a little more as its meltwater warms from 32F to your target. Water gives up 1 BTU per pound for every degree it drops, and a gallon weighs 8.34 lb. Put those together and the ice for one cool-down is:
The ice formula, with sources
lb of ice = gallons x 8.34 x (water F - target F) / (144 + target F - 32)
- 8.34
- Pounds per US gallon of water: a US gallon is 3.785 litres (Wikipedia, Gallon), at about 1 kg per litre and 2.2046 lb per kg.
- 1 BTU
- Heat to change one pound of water by 1F (EIA).
- 144
- BTU absorbed per pound of ice as it melts. The latent heat of ice is 333.55 J/g (Wikipedia, Enthalpy of fusion), which is 143.4 BTU/lb at 1,055 J per BTU (Wikipedia, BTU). We use the round 144; the difference is under 0.5%.
- Price
- 18.8 cents a pound: Reddy Ice 10 lb for $1.88 (Walmart) and Home City 20 lb for $3.74 (Walmart), both read Oct 7, 2026.
- Leaves out
- Heat that leaks in while the ice melts, and ice colder than 32F. Real use needs somewhat more than this.
What that means for a typical fill of 70 gallons (a 100-gallon tank holds about 66 gallons in practice, per one DIY guide):
- From 60F water to 50F: 36 lb of ice, about $6.77.
- From 70F garage water to 50F: 72 lb, about $13.55.
- From 80F summer patio water to 50F: 108 lb, about $20.32.
The same arithmetic shows a common figure is too low: a calculator site says a 100-gallon tub needs 40 to 60 lb to go from a 70F tap to 50F. By the formula above, that job takes 103 lb, and 50 lb of ice leaves 100 gallons near 60F. Shop by the pound, not the bag: Reddy Ice is moving its 10 lb bag to 7 lb and offers retailers the option to keep the 10 lb price.
When a chiller pays for itself
At 4 plunges a week (17.3 a month) and $6.77 of ice each time, ice costs about $117 a month. Two chiller sellers, Pod Company and Titan, say a chiller costs $0.50 to $1.50 a day to run, about $15 to $45 a month. Those are seller claims, not measurements. With them:
- The Polar Dive PRO costs $1,049 with its chiller and $559 without, so the chiller adds $490. It pays back in 5 to 7 months.
- The Ice Barrel chiller adds $3,999.99 to the barrel. It pays back in 39 to 55 months, and it carries a 1-year warranty.
How we calculated the payback
months = chiller price / (ice a month - power a month)
- Ice a month
- 4 x 52 / 12 = 17.3 plunges x $6.77 = $117
- Polar Dive
- $490 / ($117 - $45) = 6.8; $490 / ($117 - $15) = 4.8
- Ice Barrel
- $3,999.99 / ($117 - $45) = 55; $3,999.99 / ($117 - $15) = 39
What a chiller costs to run
We found no owner or reviewer who has published a kWh measurement; Garage Gym Reviews, BarBend and Wired publish none. So the yearly costs in the table at the top are a model. It adds up the heat that leaks in through the tub walls and lid at the air temperature you pick, then divides by a chiller efficiency we back out of each maker's own pull-down claim. Plunge, for example, says the All-In cools 105 gallons by 10 to 12F an hour. At 11F, that is 105 x 8.34 x 11 = 9,633 BTU an hour, or 2.8 kW of cooling.
What we can pin down is the ceiling: the cost if the chiller never switches off. That is the failure one Plunge owner describes on Trustpilot: the chiller lost its temperature reading, ran nonstop, and the household bill hit $722 in a month. A healthy chiller cycles on and off and costs a fraction of this.
If the chiller ran nonstop: rated draw x 24 hours at 18.31 cents per kWh (EIA, US residential average, July 2026). Where a maker gives amps only, we use amps x 120V, which overstates watts slightly.
| Chiller | Rated draw | kWh a day | A day | A year |
| Penguin Journey and Summit, Cold Life (spec) | 450 W | 10.8 | $1.98 | $722 |
| Nordic Wave Gen 2 Pro (FAQ) | 3.9 A, about 468 W | 11.2 | $2.06 | $751 |
| Renu Cold Stoic 3.0, cooling (spec) | 518 W | 12.4 | $2.28 | $831 |
| Plunge Chill 1/3 hp (spec) | 600 W | 14.4 | $2.64 | $962 |
| Desert Plunge 1/4 hp (spec) | 6.5 A, about 780 W | 18.7 | $3.43 | $1,251 |
| Pod Company Chiller 2.0 (spec) | 780 W | 18.7 | $3.43 | $1,251 |
| Sun Home Cold Plunge Pro (spec sheet) | 12 A, about 1,440 W | 34.6 | $6.33 | $2,310 |
Adding a chiller to a tub you already own? Our chiller guide sizes standalone chillers by gallons and BTU.
Pod Company's claim of $0.50 to $1.50 a day for its 780 W chiller implies the compressor runs about 15% to 44% of the time. A cover helps: one Ice Pod buyer writes that with the insulated cover, "the compressor seldom runs" (Pod Company review, May 2026).